Images

Slider image thumbail number 1
Slider image thumbail number 2
Slider image thumbail number 3
Slider image thumbail number 4
Slider image thumbail number 5
Slider image thumbail number 6
Slider image thumbail number 7
Slider image thumbail number 8
Slider image thumbail number 9
Slider image thumbail number 10
Slider image thumbail number 11
Slider image thumbail number 12
Slider image thumbail number 13
Slider image thumbail number 14
Slider image thumbail number 15
Slider image thumbail number 16
Slider image thumbail number 17
Slider image thumbail number 18
Slider image thumbail number 19
Slider image thumbail number 20
Slider image thumbail number 21
Slider image thumbail number 22
Slider image thumbail number 23
Slider image thumbail number 24
Slider image thumbail number 25
Slider image thumbail number 26
Slider image thumbail number 27
Slider image thumbail number 28
Slider image thumbail number 29
Slider image thumbail number 30
Slider image thumbail number 31
Slider image thumbail number 32
Slider image thumbail number 33
Slider image thumbail number 34
Slider image thumbail number 35
Slider image thumbail number 36

Map

Directions

Subject property is on south side of New Haven Ave, east of S Anthony Blvd, West of Birchwood Ave

Description

Step into history with this extraordinary former St. Andrew’s Catholic Church, built in 1911 and offering well over 18,000 sq. ft., featuring stunning early 20th-century architecture. Nestled on 1.33 acres of private land, this versatile property boasts a 4600sq ft adjoined living quarters, two full kitchens, multiple bathrooms, and expansive outdoor spaces, including decks, terraces, and a fenced backyard sanctuary. The spacious dining hall/banquet area provides endless possibilities—whether you envision it as an event venue, restaurant, boutique hotel, or creative coworking space. This unique property could also be transformed into a brewery, yoga studio, wellness center, art gallery, or retail destination. It’s ideal for a nonprofit, community organization, or even an educational facility. For those seeking to preserve its original purpose, this space could easily continue to serve as a house of worship or religious community center. Whether you reimagine it or maintain its spiritual roots, the potential for this historic gem is boundless. Don’t miss out on owning a rare piece of history with limitless opportunities!

Details

  • Property Details

  • MLS #:
    202438490
  • Price
    $1,350,000
  • Approx. Lot Size Acres
    1.33
  • Approx. Lot Size SqFt
    57,935
  • Class
    Commercial
  • DOM
    2
  • Lot Dimensions
    200 x 293 x 200 x 293
  • New Construction
    No
  • Parcel ID#
    02-13-07-402-001.001-074
  • Property Sub-Type
    Special Purpose
  • State
    IN
  • Subdivision
    None
  • Year Built
    1927
  • Zip
    46803
  • Interior Features

  • Other Features

  • Waterfront Y/N
    No

Last updated: January 17 2025, 12:44 PM

Listing courtesy of: Tyler Secrist, CENTURY 21 Bradley Realty, Inc

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Calculator

Number of Payments

Monthly Payments

$

Similar Listings

All Listings
View all

Listings